A console comparison starts with the games and features you will use, then puts a cost on that particular setup. A cheaper console with more paid games can cost more over time; a larger subscription can also cost more than buying the few games you actually finish. Neither result follows from the brand name alone.
This guide gives you a five-year budget you can reproduce in the console ownership calculator. All dollar amounts in the worked example are hypothetical inputs, not current PS5, Xbox or Nintendo prices. Collect your own checkout prices before deciding.

Collect six inputs before comparing
- Upfront checkout total. Include the console, sales tax, delivery and any equipment required for the games you want. A disc drive or extra controller belongs in the budget if your chosen setup needs it. Count each item once.
- Membership spending. Record the renewal price and billing period, not just a trial or introductory price. Use the official PlayStation Plus support page, Xbox Game Pass plans, or Nintendo Switch Online membership comparison to check what is included. Confirm your region’s actual checkout total.
- Games bought separately. List the games you expect to buy even with a membership. Include DLC and in-game purchases only if you intend to spend on them. Do not treat every catalog game as a purchase you avoided.
- Electricity while playing. Enter measured wall-plug watts for your setup if available, hours per week and your electricity price. The example below chooses a wattage to demonstrate arithmetic; it does not claim a measurement of a particular console.
- Extras and replacements. Include storage, controllers and any chosen replacement allowance. A controller that comes in the box should not appear twice.
- End value. Use your own resale assumption after fees and postage. Run a second comparison with resale set to zero; a future sale is uncertain.
Before paying for online play, check the actual games. Sony says most PS4 and PS5 online multiplayer games require PlayStation Plus, but some do not. A membership is therefore not a universal cost of playing any game online. PlayStation’s own explanation
The formula
For a fixed number of years:
Total = console checkout price + extras + years × (annual membership + games per year × average game price + annual playing electricity) − resale.
Annual playing electricity = watts ÷ 1,000 × hours per week × 52 × electricity price in dollars per kWh.
If your electricity input is in cents, divide it by 100 first. This model assumes the same annual spending and usage throughout. It excludes borrowing costs, price changes, repairs beyond your allowance, and electricity used outside playing sessions. Add a TV, monitor or standby estimate separately if it differs between your options. Do not add the whole household utility bill.
Worked comparison: membership spending versus games bought
Both hypothetical options use the same $600 console, $80 of extras, 200 watts while playing, 10 hours per week, 20 cents/kWh, a five-year holding period and $100 resale. The difference is how games are obtained.
| Five-year budget item | Smaller membership, more purchases | Larger membership, fewer purchases |
|---|---|---|
| Console | $600 | $600 |
| Extras | $80 | $80 |
| Membership assumption | $80/year × 5 = $400 | $180/year × 5 = $900 |
| Games bought separately | 3/year × $40 × 5 = $600 | 1/year × $40 × 5 = $200 |
| Playing electricity | $104 | $104 |
| Resale assumption | −$100 | −$100 |
| Five-year total | $1,684 | $1,784 |
Electricity checks out as 0.2 kW × 10 × 52 = 104 kWh/year; at $0.20/kWh that is $20.80/year or $104 over five years. The larger membership costs $500 more and avoids $400 of separate game purchases in this scenario. It ends up $100 more expensive, even though the game-purchase line looks much smaller.
The extra annual membership cost is $100. At $40 for a game you would otherwise buy, it needs to replace more than 2.5 purchases per year to save money: three full $40 purchases saves $120 against that $100 premium. This test assumes the games are included when you want them and you would otherwise have bought them. More games played is not automatically more money saved.

Run the comparison with your own library
In the calculator, enter your console price, annual membership, game purchases, play time, electricity and resale. Record the breakdown, then change only the membership and games you genuinely expect to buy. Keep the other inputs identical so the difference means something.
Next repeat with one fewer game purchase avoided each year and with no resale. In the example, avoiding one fewer $40 purchase per year adds $200 over five years. That change is larger than the initial $100 gap. The useful question is how confidently you can predict those purchases, rather than which setup wins on a single total.
For a different console, first check that the games, controllers, storage and play modes you need are available. Then compare complete setups over the same period. The lowest total is not a substitute for the games you wanted to play.
Sources and correction
Official membership pages above were checked October 25, 2026. They establish plan features and where to obtain a local offer; the example’s prices, wattage, play time and resale are our chosen assumptions. We have not tested these consoles or measured their power consumption.
Correction, October 25, 2026: this page previously presented a dated console price-hike table, brand-specific power estimates and a universal subscription requirement without adequate supporting links. Those claims have been removed. The guide now separates verified provider information from a reproducible budget exercise. See our editorial policy.